Wickedly Good Witch Hat Cookies

Share this post with friends! This post may contain affiliate links.

Wickedly Good Witch Hat Cookies

What’s better than making fun Halloween crafts with your kids? Making ones that are edible also! I’ve never made edible play dough before my family is already requesting that I make it again. These adorable witch hat cookies would be a big hit at Halloween parties or celebrations. 

This is a step-by-step post on how to make the Wickedly Good Witch Hat Cookies but there is also a video down at the bottom if you’d prefer to watch.

This post is brought to you by Dixie Crystals. You can find more fun crafts like this one in their Kid’s Kitchen.

Here is what you will need to make Wickedly Good Witch Hat Cookies:

Dixie Crystals Confectioners Sugar


Green Fondant

OREO Cookies

Smooth Peanut Butter Wickedly Good Witch Hat Cookies

I decided to use Chocolate OREO cookies so that it looked more like a black witch hat. Wickedly Good Witch Hat Cookies

Mix the Dixie Crystals Confectioners Sugar, honey, and peanut butter in a bowl. When it becomes too thick to stir knead the dough with your hands until it well blended. The dough should be soft enough to be pliable and not sticky.Wickedly Good Witch Hat Cookies

You could add food colorings to the edible play dough to make it nice and colorful but since we are covering the dough with OREO crumbs there is no need to. But for future products and molding you may. Make sure you store it in an air tight container.
Wickedly Good Witch Hat Cookies

Now we need to half a few OREO cookies and scrap out the middle so that we can crumble the cookies. I’m not going to lie I ate it. Don’t judge me, because it was so good and totally worth it. Wickedly Good Witch Hat Cookies

I place the cookies into a plastic bag and used a rolling pin to crumble and crush the cookies. Wickedly Good Witch Hat CookiesGrab about a tablespoon sized amount of dough and shape it into the point of the hat. 

Wickedly Good Witch Hat Cookies

Dip the point into your cookie crumbs or roll them. Be sure to leave the bottom portion of the dough free of crumbs to make sure it sticks to the cookie. Place the point on the top of an OREO cookie pressing down to make sure it is secure. You can also use a small amount of icing if you need to. Wickedly Good Witch Hat Cookies

Roll your fondant very thin like ribbon and cut into tiny strips to wrap around the hats. To get the fondant to stick to itself when it crosses just wet the area that touches. There you have adorable witch hat cookies. Witch Hat Cookies



Wickedly Good Witch Hat Cookies

Dixie Crystals
These wickedly good witch hats are easy to make and a yummy themed food for Halloween.
No ratings yet
Print Pin Rate
Prep Time 40 mins
Total Time 40 mins
Servings 12
Calories 3749 kcal

What you will need

  • Oreo cookies
  • Green fondant
  • 1 cup peanut butter
  • 1/2 cup honey
  • 2 Cup Dixie Crystals Confectioners Powdered Sugar


  • To make edible playdough: use your hands to mix peanut butter, honey and powdered sugar in large bowl. The dough should be soft enough to be pliable and not sticky.
  • Shape dough into a cone shape for the top of witch hat.
  • In a ziplock bag, crush several Oreo cookies (without the creamy filling) into small pieces.
  • Empty crushed cookies onto a plate and roll each "playdough" witch hat in the Oreos until coated
  • Place coated hat on top of Oreo cookies. If the hat doesn't want to stay, you can use a dollop of canned icing to hold it in place.
  • Cut a thin strip of green fondant to make a band for the hat. Attach to cookie at the base of the cone-shaped top.


Did you make this?Tag @JaMonkey on social media or hastag your post with #JaMonkey!

Share this post with friends! This post may contain affiliate links.

Related Articles



Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Meghan Cooper is a writer, content creator, movie critic, and geek living in Atlanta, Ga. She loves movies, traveling, and lots of coffee. Member of the Southeastern Film Critics Association, Georgia Film Critics Association, and Atlanta Film Critics Circle.

Movie Lovers

Do you love movies? How about seeing movies before anyone else? We always have great advanced screening passes for JaMonkey followers. Email subscribers and social media followers get first dibs!

Latest Articles